| Players of the Year | ||||
| Year | Regular | Senior | MID AMATEUR | JUNIOR |
| 2023 | Bryce Haney | Pete Betzold | Jeff Scohy | |
| 2022 | Austin Greaser | Dave Clancy | Jeff Scohy | |
| 2021 | Austin Greaser | Curt Cranmer | Jeff Scohy | |
| 2020 | Austin Greaser | Tim Sorrows | Jeff Scohy | Jordan Gilkison |
| 2019 | Peter Samborsky II | Pete Betzold | Austin Greaser | |
| 2018 | Jeff Scohy | Ron Eubel | ||
| 2017 | Austin Sipe | Dan DeVore | ||
| 2016 | Jeff Scohy | Dan DeVore | ||
| 2015 | Jeff Scohy | Tim Sorrows | ||
| 2014 | Jeff Scohy | Tim Sorrows | ||
| 2013 | Nick Scott | Dan DeVore | ||
| 2012 | Jeff Scohy | Dan DeVore | ||
| 2011 | Nick Scott | Bob Jones | ||
| 2010 | Michael Bernard | Bob Jones | ||
| 2009 | Alex Martin | Bob Jones | ||
| 2008 | Jeff Scohy | Juan Muzquiz | ||
| 2007 | Peter Samborsky II | Gordon Willins | ||
| 2006 | Peter Samborsky II | Chuck Parsons | ||
