| |
| Senior Metropolitan | Mid Amateur |
| 2017 - Dan DeVore - Sycamore Creek CC | 2017 - Brady Marinangeli |
| 2016 - Dan DeVore - Sugar Valley GC | 2016- Dan DeVore |
| 2015 - Tim Sorrows - Walnut Grove CC | 2015 - Mark Monfort |
| 2014 - Tim Sorrows - Miami Valley GC | 2014 - Jeff Scohy |
| 2013 - Dave Larger - Piqua CC | Began in 2014 |
| 2012 - Tal Selby - Browns Run CC | |
| 2011 - Tim Sorrows - Yankee Trace GC | |
| 2010 - Bob Jones - Sugar Valley CC | |
| 2009 - Bob Jones - Browns Run CC | |
| 2008 - Bob Jones - Dayton CC | |
| 2007 - Dan Devore - Meadowbrook CC | |
| 2006 - Bob Eardley - Country Club of the North | |
| 2005 - Doug Gage - Urbana CC | |
| 2004 - Jeff Serena - Twin Base GC | |
| 2003 - Jack Sayers - Troy CC | |
| 2002 - Skip Snow - Springfield CC | |
| 2001 - Skip Snow - Meadowbrook CC | |
| 2000 - Gene Bayman - Piqua CC | |
| 1999 - Karl Heffner - Meadowbrook CC | |
| 1998 - Not Held | |
| 1997 - Karl Heffner* - Yankee-Cassel-Shaker | |
| 1996 - Karl Heffner* - Yankee-Cassel-Shaker | |
| * Held in Conjuction with the Metropolitian | |
